​
Buckeye Benefit Consulting LLC
  • 614-655-5635
  • Products
    • Employee Benefits
    • Life
    • Personal Lines
    • Business Insurance
  • About Us
    • Blogs
    • Our Companies
    • Our Team
  • Get A Quote
  • Contact Us

Company Contacts and Websites

Listed below are many of our carriers phone numbers and websites for your convenience. Simply click the name to be taken to the carrier website.

Allied - A Division of Nationwide
Personal Service/Claims - 800-282-1446
Commercial Service/Claims - 866-322-3214

Anthem Blue Cross/Blue Shield
Pharmacy - 800-962-8192
Dental - 800-282-1730
Vision - 866-723-0515
Life - 800-551-7265
BlueCard - 800-810-2583
Medicare Supplement - 866-649-2037
Plans & Benefits: number on your card
Self Service - Policyholder Website:  
https://www.anthem.com/login/


Encompass - A Division of Allstate
24 Hour Customer Service/Claims Service - 800-262-9262

Foremost - Property
After hours Customer Service/Claims -  800-532-4221

Grange Mutual Insurance
Customer Service/Claims – 800-422-0550

 

Liberty Mutual

Customer Service - 800-290-7977
24 Hour Claims - 844-339-7453

Roadside Assistance - 800-426-9898​

MAPFRE - American Commerce
24 hour Claims Service – 800-222-2114

Medical Mutual of Ohio
Customer Care - 800-382-5729
Online Help/Tech Support - 800-218-2205
Self Service - Policyholder Website:

https://member.medmutual.com/user/login.aspx?returnUrl=https%3a%2f%2fmember.medmutual.com%2f
​
Metlife Property & Casualty
Claims:  1-800-854-6011

Progressive
24 Hour Customer Service/Claims Service - 877-776-2436
Self Service - Policyholder Website:

Safeco - A Division of Liberty Mutual
24 Hour Customer Service/Claims Service – 866-472-3326

Travelers
24 Hour Customer Service/Claims Services - 800-872-8737
 


United Healthcare
Customer Service/Claims - 866-633-2446
Policyholder Website:
https://www.myuhc.com/member/prewelcome.do?psnName=link.nav.top.login&requestor=/public_topNav

​Website by Baytech Companies, LLC